Sunday, September 4, 2011

There is no Truth

Science Fiction class was interesting again. We read Isaac Asimov's 'Liar' for class and discussed it afterward.  We did not really discuss the story itself. We discussed the psychological and philosophical elements behind it. It was all very vague.  Professor X started talking about Truth. Truth with a capital 'T', objective truth, the one and only Truth, and that's one of my favorite topics
It was difficult to understand what the point of his long explanation was, but I believe the gist of the whole thing was that there is no Truth. That was his own personal belief anyway.

I couldn't contain myself. It was perfect. It was too perfect. So perfect that I doubted myself the second after I blurted "THAT'S A FALLACY PROFESSOR X!" He cocked his head in the same manner as he did during the Lord of the Rings conversation and I vibrated and spluttered about trying to explain myself.

"I'm sure you've heard of it. I mean, obviously you've heard of it. You've heard of it, right?"

Who hasn't heard of it? How can anyone declare that there is no truth, when that declaration is supposed to be considered a truth in itself.  I mean that's super tight logic. It's the easiest argument.  Professors of literature, be they community college teachers or tenured Harvard academics, have heard of it.  That's why I felt silly telling him straight out. It felt like I was stating the obvious.

The fact that he even made the absurd statement should have assuaged the doubts I had about my argument.  The only problem was that I never really heard him say that there is no truth.  He covered this definite objective statement in a tangle of vague ideas and theory jargon.  He chuckled when I asked him if he believed that there was no truth and then he tried to explain how it was all bigger than just one statement since everyone filters things differently (is that not an objective statement?). Then he started explaining how this relativity applied to stem cell research.  The whole class nodded along.  I felt like the only objective person in the room.  That, of course is not true, since each student holds his or her own objective beliefs.

No comments:

Post a Comment